Inheriting an IRA can create an odd temptation: do nothing.
The account is still invested. The deadline may be years away. And delaying taxable withdrawals can feel like the obvious choice.
But for many beneficiaries, the 10-year rule is a deadline—not necessarily a strategy.
A more useful question is: How should you use the years available to you? The best approach often depends on your beneficiary status, when the original owner died, whether they reached their required beginning date (RBD), and whether the account is traditional or Roth.
The 10-Year Rule Is a Deadline, Not a Default Plan
For many non-spouse beneficiaries inheriting an IRA from someone who died after 2019, the general rule is that the account must be emptied by the end of the 10th year after death. (Some “eligible designated beneficiaries”—including surviving spouses, minor children of the owner, disabled or chronically ill individuals, and certain beneficiaries close in age to the owner—may have different options.)
What the rule doesn’t automatically mean is: leave everything untouched until year 10 and then withdraw the full balance.
Waiting can preserve tax-deferred growth (or tax-free growth in a Roth). But waiting can also compress taxes into fewer years—potentially turning the final year into a large, avoidable income spike.
Step One: Confirm Which Rules Apply to You
Before deciding on timing, confirm what kind of beneficiary you are. Rules can differ significantly among:
- Surviving spouses
- Eligible designated beneficiaries
- Non-spouse designated beneficiaries
- Non-individual beneficiaries (estates, some trusts, charities)
This is why it can be risky to copy what a sibling, friend, or coworker did. Their beneficiary classification—and therefore their rules—may not match yours.
Step Two: Establish Key Facts Before You Withdraw
Inherited IRA planning goes better when you start with a clean fact pattern. Early on, confirm:
- Date of death of the original owner (rules changed for many accounts after 2019)
- Type of IRA (traditional vs. Roth)
- Your beneficiary status
- Whether the owner reached their required beginning date
- Whether there are multiple beneficiaries or a trust involved
These details may also affect whether annual required minimum distributions (RMDs) apply during the 10-year period.
The 10-Year Rule Doesn’t Always Mean “No Withdrawals Until the End”
A common misconception is that the 10-year rule always allows beneficiaries to take nothing in years 1–9 as long as the account is emptied by year 10.
In some situations, beneficiaries may have annual distribution requirements during the 10-year window, depending in part on whether the original owner died before or after their RBD.
That creates two separate questions:
- Is there a minimum amount I must withdraw this year? (compliance)
- Should I voluntarily withdraw more than the minimum? (planning)
Don’t Miss the Year-of-Death RMD
One detail that can slip through the cracks: if the original owner was required to take an RMD in the year they died but didn’t take the full amount, the remaining year-of-death RMD generally still needs to be distributed.
This is worth verifying early with the custodian and your tax professional—ideally well before year-end.
Map the Tax Years You Have—Not Just the Deadline
Once you know what’s required, the planning value comes from looking across the full 10-year window.
For example, if you inherit an IRA at 62 and plan to retire at 65, your income may change materially within the distribution period. Your 10 years could include:
- High earnings years while working
- Lower-income years right after retirement
- The start of Social Security
- A pension start date
- Your own future RMDs
- A large capital gain or business sale
- A move to a different state
Instead of treating each year as identical, consider a year-by-year projection. Often, the goal is to avoid pushing yourself into higher brackets unnecessarily—while still staying flexible.
Think in Tax Brackets (and Side Effects), Not Just “Taxes”
Inherited traditional IRA withdrawals typically add to taxable income. So the real question usually isn’t “How much tax will I pay on $50,000?” but rather:
What other income will already be filling my brackets that year?
Also remember: higher income can ripple outward. For retirees, increased modified adjusted gross income may affect Medicare premiums and can change how much Social Security is taxable. It doesn’t mean “never withdraw.” It means coordinate decisions so there are fewer surprises.
Waiting Can Preserve Tax Deferral—But May Reduce Flexibility
Delaying distributions can make sense in some cases, especially when you expect your income to drop later.
But there’s a tradeoff. If the account grows and you reach year 8 with a large remaining balance, you’ve limited your remaining “planning runway.” If income turns out higher than expected late in the window, you may be forced into larger distributions in less favorable years.
In other words, the decision isn’t only “tax deferral vs. paying taxes now.” It can also be flexibility now vs. fewer choices later.
Cash Needs and Investing Still Matter
Taxes are important, but they aren’t the only variable.
If you need funds for debt reduction, healthcare, home repairs, family support, or building reserves, that belongs in the plan. Likewise, inherited IRAs are investment accounts—distribution timing affects what you sell, how you rebalance, and the risk you’re carrying relative to the rest of your portfolio.
A Practical Approach: Build a Distribution Calendar
Rather than making a brand-new decision every December, consider building a simple “working calendar” for years 1–10 that tracks:
- Any required distributions
- Estimated total household income
- Expected tax bracket
- Social Security/pension start dates
- Planned capital gains or major deductions
- Large purchases or charitable goals
Then create a review rule—revisit the plan when tax laws change, income changes, markets move significantly, or retirement begins.
The Better Question Isn’t “Now or Later?”
An inherited IRA can give you something valuable: time. The goal is usually not to withdraw everything immediately—and not to default to waiting until the last moment either.
Instead, confirm the rules, identify what’s required each year (if anything), map your income across the period, coordinate with your tax plan and investments, and decide how to use the window deliberately.
Click here to schedule a conversation.
If you’ve inherited an IRA and want to coordinate withdrawals with retirement income, taxes, and investment strategy, a planning conversation can help clarify what must happen—and what choices you still have.